Wayfair vs Amazon for Home Brands: Where Should You Focus?
Home and garden brands often face a choice between Amazon and Wayfair. Both are significant channels, but they serve different buyer needs and have meaningfully different operational requirements. This guide helps you choose.
For brands in home furnishings, garden, lighting, bedding, and home décor, Amazon and Wayfair are the two most significant online marketplace opportunities in the UK. Both can generate substantial revenue. But they are built on different models, serve different buyer mindsets, and reward different operational approaches.
Understanding the differences, and why many home brands should eventually be on both, helps you make better decisions about sequencing and resource allocation.
Buyer Intent and Shopping Behaviour
Amazon buyers in home categories are typically searching for a specific product type. They search "blackout curtains 90x90 eyelet" or "garden bistro set 2 chairs" and compare options on price, reviews, and brand. They are in research mode but have a clear purchase intent. The average consideration time before purchase on Amazon is relatively short, often minutes within a single session.
Wayfair buyers have a slightly different behaviour pattern. Wayfair is a dedicated home destination; people visit Wayfair specifically to browse home products. They may spend significantly longer on the platform, exploring categories, saving items to wishlists, and returning multiple times before purchasing. The purchase consideration cycle is longer, but the buyer is deeply in home-purchase mode.
This difference in behaviour has implications for what works commercially. Amazon rewards competitive pricing and strong review counts. Wayfair rewards strong imagery, detailed product information, and catalogue breadth.
Imagery Requirements
This is the most significant practical difference between the two platforms.
Amazon requires clean white-background product imagery and recommends lifestyle images. The imagery bar for Amazon is high, but it is achievable without specialist home photography.
Wayfair requires room scene imagery for most furniture, lighting, and décor categories. Room scene images show the product in a styled interior context, a sofa in a living room, a light fitting in a bedroom, a rug under a dining table. Producing room scene imagery at the quality Wayfair expects is a meaningful investment, often requiring professional photography or high-quality CGI renders.
For home brands considering Wayfair, the imagery investment is the primary upfront cost consideration. It is, however, a worthwhile investment, room scene imagery significantly improves conversion rates by helping customers visualise the product in their own home.
Fee and Margin Comparison
Amazon for home categories: referral fees typically 8–12% depending on exact category, plus FBA fees if applicable (significant for large or heavy items). For large home items (sofas, bed frames), FBA may not be practical; self-fulfilment with large-item carriers becomes the model, adding cost and complexity.
Wayfair operates on a wholesale/supplier model. You set a supplier price; Wayfair marks it up and sells at retail. Your margin is the difference between your cost and your supplier price. For large items with high average order values, Wayfair's model can produce strong per-unit margins even at competitive supplier pricing, because the items are genuinely valuable.
Returns on Wayfair are an important consideration. Large home items (furniture, lighting) have higher return rates than small consumer products, and return logistics for large items are expensive. Build realistic return costs into your Wayfair margin modelling.
Categories: Where Each Wins
Amazon is stronger for: smaller home accessories, bedding and textiles, kitchen products, garden tools and accessories, storage, and décor items below £50. The high search volume and Prime ecosystem work well for these categories.
Wayfair is stronger for: furniture, large garden furniture, lighting, beds and mattresses, rugs, and premium décor items with higher average order values. Wayfair's dedicated home focus and room scene imagery create a more appropriate discovery environment for considered home purchases.
Logistics: The Large Item Challenge
Large home items, furniture, garden furniture, wardrobes, present specific logistics challenges on both platforms.
Amazon FBA is rarely practical for large items due to storage costs and oversized fee structures. Amazon FBM (Fulfilled by Merchant) with a specialist two-person delivery carrier is the more common model, but managing this at scale requires robust logistics partnerships.
Wayfair has an established logistics framework for large items through its Wayfair Delivery Network, and has strong carrier relationships for two-person delivery. Suppliers using Wayfair's logistics framework benefit from an infrastructure that is genuinely built for large home items.
Which to Prioritise?
For most home brands, Amazon first if you are not already there, the audience volume and the accessibility of FBA (for smaller items) make it the natural starting point.
Add Wayfair for larger items, furniture, and garden furniture where Wayfair's dedicated home buyer base and room scene imagery create a more appropriate conversion environment than Amazon's search results.
Many successful home brands run Amazon and Wayfair as complementary channels, Amazon for smaller home accessories at competitive price points, Wayfair for their furniture and garden furniture range.
Our Marketplace Expansion Agency manages both Amazon and Wayfair as part of integrated multi-channel programmes for home brands.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Wayfair take all home brands?
No. Wayfair has a supplier application process and expects a minimum catalogue depth (typically 20+ SKUs). They are selective about category fit and imagery quality.
Can I use FBA on Amazon for furniture?
FBA is rarely practical for large furniture items. Amazon FBM with a two-person delivery carrier is the more common model for furniture and large home items.
Which has higher average order values, Amazon or Wayfair?
Wayfair typically has higher average order values in furniture and large garden categories. Amazon is often stronger for smaller home accessories where the convenience and Prime delivery are key purchase drivers.
Do I need different imagery for Amazon and Wayfair?
Yes. Amazon requires white background images and recommends lifestyle shots. Wayfair requires room scene imagery for most furniture and décor categories. Budget for separate photography or CGI production for each platform.
How do I manage returns for large home items?
Returns on large items require specialist carrier management. Wayfair's logistics framework can help here. For Amazon, you need to establish carrier agreements for large item collection and management before launching large SKUs.
Free download
Free Marketplace Expansion Checklist
Find out which marketplaces your brand should launch on next and what to prepare before applying.
No spam. Practical ecommerce growth insights only.
Want to know what's possible for your brand?
Book a free 45-minute call. We'll review your current channels and tell you honestly what marketplace expansion could add.
Book Your Free Marketplace Call →