Why Relying on Amazon and Shopify Is a Risk, Not a Strategy
Most consumer brands are heavily dependent on one or two sales channels. Here's why that's a structural risk, what multi-marketplace expansion actually looks like in practice, and how brands have grown their revenue by 30–60% without changing their products.
If your brand generates most of its revenue from Amazon and your own Shopify store, you are not alone. This is the most common sales structure for consumer brands in the UK right now. It is also a structural vulnerability that most brands do not recognise until something goes wrong.
The Concentration Problem
Amazon and Shopify together account for a significant share of UK e-commerce. But relying on them exclusively creates three specific risks:
Platform risk. Amazon can suppress your listings, suspend your account, or change its algorithm. These events happen without warning and can devastate revenue overnight. Brands with no alternative channels have no cushion.
Margin pressure. Amazon's fees have increased consistently over the past five years. FBA costs, referral fees, and advertising spend mean that many brands are achieving gross margins on Amazon that they would never accept through another channel. Diversification gives you commercial leverage, and better average margins across your portfolio.
Discovery limitation. A customer who does not shop on Amazon or Shopify will never find your product, no matter how good it is. You are invisible to them. That is a real and addressable revenue gap.
What the Alternative Looks Like
Multi-marketplace expansion is not about being everywhere for the sake of it. It is about identifying the three to five channels where your products are most likely to sell well, and building a presence there systematically.
For most UK consumer brands, the most relevant additional channels are:
- eBay, still the UK's second-largest marketplace, with a massive and loyal buyer base that is fundamentally different from Amazon's
- TikTok Shop, the fastest-growing sales channel in UK e-commerce, particularly powerful for products that can be demonstrated on video
- Wayfair, the dominant destination for home, garden, and furniture brands with a dedicated, high-intent audience
- B&Q Marketplace, high-intent DIY and home improvement shoppers with a clear purchasing project in mind
- Debenhams, fashion, beauty, home, and lifestyle with a strong British heritage audience
- Temu, growing rapidly in the UK with a value-oriented buyer base that is genuinely additive for brands with the right price points
- Tesco Marketplace, grocery shoppers with trust in the Tesco brand, looking for household and lifestyle products
The right combination depends on your category, margins, and operational capacity.
The Revenue Maths
Consider a brand doing £50,000 per month across Amazon and Shopify. If a thoughtful expansion onto two additional marketplaces adds just £8,000 per month in combined revenue, conservative for a well-managed expansion, that is a 16% increase in total revenue from products and infrastructure you already have.
In practice, we see more than this. The brands we manage typically add 30–60% to their total revenue within the first 12 months of a multi-marketplace expansion programme. The ceiling depends on category, product range, and how actively the new channels are managed.
These are not exceptional results for exceptional brands. They are what happens when established brands with good products get into the right channels and manage them properly.
The Real Opportunity: New Audiences
One of the most important things to understand about multi-marketplace expansion is that it largely reaches new audiences, not the same customers through different channels.
A customer who discovers your brand on TikTok Shop because a creator was demonstrating your product in their kitchen is almost certainly not the same person who finds you via an Amazon search for "airtight food containers 5 litre." The TikTok discovery customer was not looking for your product; it found them. The Amazon search customer was actively looking. Both represent genuine demand for your product; neither would necessarily appear in the other channel.
This is why marketplace revenue is mostly incremental. The same product, reaching new audiences, through new discovery mechanisms, generating revenue that would not otherwise exist.
The Operational Question
The most common objection to marketplace expansion is operational: "We don't have the resource to manage more channels."
This is a legitimate concern if you are planning to manage each channel manually, in-house. It is less of a concern if you are working with an agency that handles listing creation, inventory management, order processing, and customer service across all channels on your behalf.
The brands that scale fastest are the ones that treat marketplace expansion as a managed service rather than an internal project. Internal projects require dedicated resource that most growing brands do not have. A managed service converts the resource question into a commercial one: does the revenue generated by the expansion programme justify the management fee? For our clients, consistently yes.
What to Do Next
If you are generating consistent revenue on Amazon or Shopify and want to understand what multi-marketplace expansion could realistically add to your business, the first step is a straightforward conversation.
We offer a free 45-minute Marketplace Opportunity Call where we review your current channels, identify the most relevant marketplaces for your products, and give you an honest view of the revenue opportunity, at no cost and with no obligation.
Our Marketplace Expansion Agency has expanded consumer brands onto Amazon, eBay, TikTok Shop, Temu, B&Q, Tesco, Debenhams, Wayfair, and The Range. Our Marketplace Management Services handle the ongoing management of all active channels as a coordinated programme.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will marketplace expansion cannibalise my existing Amazon and Shopify revenue?
Not materially, in our experience. Different marketplace audiences discover products through different mechanisms. The customer who finds you on eBay or TikTok Shop is largely not the same customer who was buying from you on Amazon. Total revenue grows; individual channel revenue stays broadly stable.
How much does multi-marketplace expansion cost?
The main costs are marketplace fees (a percentage of each sale), any content production required for new channels, and the cost of the managed service (if not managing in-house). Our fees vary by scope, book a call for a specific proposal.
How quickly can we expect results?
Amazon and eBay typically generate meaningful revenue within two to three months of going live. TikTok Shop can move faster. Retail marketplaces (Tesco, B&Q) take longer to ramp due to application and approval timelines.
Do we need to change our products for different marketplaces?
No. The same products work across channels; what changes is the content, the positioning, and the advertising strategy for each platform. Product development is not a prerequisite for marketplace expansion.
What is the first step?
Book a free Marketplace Opportunity Call and we will walk you through the opportunity for your specific brand.
Free download
Free Marketplace Expansion Checklist
Find out which marketplaces your brand should launch on next and what to prepare before applying.
No spam. Practical ecommerce growth insights only.
Want to know what's possible for your brand?
Book a free 45-minute call. We'll review your current channels and tell you honestly what marketplace expansion could add.
Book Your Free Marketplace Call →